Genesis Private Choice takes on 17 hospital plans and wins

best hospital plan south africa

How does paying for medical aid every month make you feel…?

Not only are you paying a ton of money every month, but you’re still having to cough up every time you claim?

Let me explain.

Hopefully you read my previous article on the Genesis Private Choice health plan. In that article, I mentioned being sceptical of medical aid schemes.

After all:

Anyone can offer the cheapest cost but what happens when you end up in hospital, get saddled with bills, and have the sheriff knocking at your door?

Elmarie Jensen – Marketing Manager at Genesis Medical Scheme – stole my thunder by referring me to an independent audit comparing 17 open schemes and their costs versus benefits.
Somehow I knew this wasn’t going to end well for me which is why you’re reading this article right now.

How could I dispute the findings of an independent auditor?

The Genesis Private Choice plan was ranked “number one” when it comes to value for money hospital plans.
Now granted, this doesn’t mean they’re the ‘host with the most’. By that I mean the audit isn’t saying Genesis Private Choice offers the most comprehensive benefit across all providers, but it does mean you’re getting the most for what you’re paying.

I mean think about this for a moment.

How many of us belong to a hospital plan which we never use? So you end up paying thousands of Rands a year for something you hope will pay your full hospital bill, if you ever end up in hospital.

But wouldn’t you like to know beforehand, whether you’re making a wise investment? That’s what makes this audit so useful. And if you’re looking for a copy, you can find a link in my previous article.

But then someone threw a spanner into the works

“That’s all fine and well, but (you know that word ‘but’) I’d rather pay an extra R200 a month and know my hospital bill is paid in full.”

Great question, right?

If it comes to paying R900 a month for a plan which covers 90% of my bill versus paying R1, 000 a month for one which pays 100% of my bill, I’d go with the more expensive one.

Much rather pay R1, 000 a month and know if I end up in hospital that the R50, 000 operation is going to get paid in full.

I thought long and hard about the question and then this occurred to me:

What if…the company charging me the R1, 000 a month ended up paying exactly the same benefit as the company charging me R900 a month? Let’s say my hospital stay cost R50, 000 and both schemes paid R50, 000.

How would you now feel about scheme B charging you R100 a month more for the same benefit? It’s the same thing as finding out you can get car insurance somewhere else at half the price!

There’s a simple solution

If you’re:

  • fit and healthy
  • haven’t been to see a doctor in years, and
  • don’t know what the inside of a hospital looks like

Go for the cheapest hospital plan you can find with a reputable medical aid company (By reputable I mean one that’s solvency ratio meets the legal requirement of 25%. The only way to climb back from a 20% solvency ratio to a 25% solvency ratio during the next year, is either by reducing the benefits you offer in the new year or increasing your cost the following year or both).

Jump onto a medical gap cover product. For instance, take the Genesis Private Choice plan as an example. This pays 100% of the Genesis medical aid rate for hospital procedures. Now 100% sounds great, but what if your specialist charges R10, 000 more than what Genesis is willing to pay for that procedure?

Gap cover would bump the Genesis medical aid rate from 100% to 500%. Now let’s assume the gap cover costs you R150 a month. Add that to the R900 a month you’re paying for Genesis Private Choice and you’re looking at R1, 050 a month.

That’s enough to cover most procedures in full, and believe me, I don’t care what medical aid you’re on, there’s an excellent chance you’ll end up having to pay in.

Now from the way I’m carrying on, you’d expect that I’m paid a commission by Genesis to say this. That’s simply not true. If you read the previous article, you’d see I lost a bet.

But ignore everything I’ve just said!

Because what I’m about to say about Genesis is what got my friend – who threw the spanner into the works – excited.

Genesis Private Choice is what’s known as a hybrid scheme.

What’s a hybrid scheme?

Take my friend as an example.

He’s on a standard networked hospital plan with gap cover. The problem is he’s never seen the inside of a hospital in ten years (Which is a good thing).

However, over those ten years he’s spent a small fortune on dentists – let’s say it’s closer to R10, 000 than R1, 000 (Hasn’t he heard of flossing?).

On top of that he’s paying:

  • R1, 100 a month for medical aid, and
  • R152 a month for gap cover
  • That’s R1, 252 a month for something he’s never used

The Genesis Private Choice plan is a hybrid plan in that it pays for dentistry.

You want to know what he said to me?

“Where do I sign up?”

“Hang on a mo,” I said. “Let me first give you an idea of what you’re getting as a dentistry benefit. You know these guys – they’ll probably have something ridiculous like one filling a year.”

And that’s where I want to end off today’s article. In the next one I’m going to tell you what I told him. So stay tuned.

Article written by InsuranceFundi.  Passionate about making insurance fun & interesting in simple English.

Related Posts